<p>If your SAT's come up in senior year, as they so often do, why not add some reach schools onto your list that are Midwestern and honor the individual? For example, Oberlin, Carleton, Macalester, or Grinnell? Dare to dream. You know you need safety, match and reach schools on your list, in addition to "financial safeties", right? Once you have some academic and financial safeties in mind, you might feel the courage to add on match and reaches. It's a bottom-up way of building a list. Why are you so sure Northwestern is out of your grasp? I'm not. At least it could be a reach on your list.</p>
<p>To figure out if you have the "stats and the money" to go somewhere, have you tried comparing your stats to the middle range of their stats on the Common Data Set for each school? Also, for money, you sound like a candidate for need-based aid, so don't just look at the sticvker price; read about their Financial Aid policies, too. Sometimes the old, established schools with the bigger endowments have more to offer as need-based financial aid.
You would first apply to them by next December, and then fill out the FAFSA forms during January and Feb that tell the whole story about your need.</p>
<p>Look especially for colleges that claim to meet a high percentage of need. Oberlin, for example, meets 100% of need. As well, if there are meritorious things about you, some of these small LAC's might pick up on it if they give some merit aid; however, that's nothing to count on. Just don't rule yourself OUT of high-sticker-cost colleges, especially if they are closer to home, </p>
<p>If everything I said above is brand new to you, that's fine, and you just need to begin reading also over at the Financial Aid part of CC, too. </p>
<p>I'm not suggesting it's easy, but aren't you capable of filling out all those FA forms? If so, stretch your vision a bit for your list. Plenty of research to do.
Good luck. (Is your GC involved, or not? If she's only processing community and state college forms, you're not alone on that). </p>
<p>On practicing Wiccan, I'm not sure what that means. My D had friends who were interested in h.s., but I saw less carryover into college. You are right that you need a place that is tolerant of differences if you want to continue to explore that practice. You might research it and not even mention it on your application, since it doesn't really bring anything positive to mind educationally; but you just want to reassure yourself that if you were to do certain unusual rites in a dorm setting, that the school is socially tolerant to diverse viewpoints, that's all. For that reason, I'd rule out Christian colleges, but stay with the secular ones.</p>