<p>You need to apply to schools with a range of selectivity levels - safety, match, and reach, just like any other student. You should still apply to NYU.</p>
<p>Does your HS have Naviance? Hopefully your GC will be able to offer some good suggestions of schools to consider.</p>
<p>Are you interested in any schools that offer non-binding EA or rolling admissions? If you got an early acceptance, you could concentrate on reach schools.</p>