After all the info is in, I would suggest after detailed pros/cons, and maybe revisit top 2. Also keep in mind if student decides to change major, or career direction. Also if considering grad school/professional school after UG, how well does UG prepare?
IMHO, a student who looks for all opportunities on where they go to school - it can be so dependent on how the student achieves where they are planted.
My DDs went where they had the best scholarships and the schools that were the best match - which coincidentally was also where they wanted to attend.
Sometimes have to really analyze cost/benefit.