OP, here is the deal: you only have one safety. Personally, and others might disagree, I can’t see you getting into any other school on your list, maybe NE or BU (is that Boston university? Boston college is a reach.) And why the changes in colleges if you apply next year? Anyway, that doesn’t matter.
If you apply now, you will have a college for next fall, which can be deferred for a year. You will be submitting your 1310, which is low for most every school on your list. If you apply in a year, you have a chance to raise your SAT. You might be able to up your chances of getting into your reach schools. You have to prioritize. It is clear you want extra time for skating before you start college. How motivated are you to get into a more selective college? If the honest answer is “very” then you need a higher SAT.