While the article does make the point that chance assessment by other students are fraught with peril, I was happy to see my point about students who lack good college counseling getting a much-needed reality check. Every year we see one or two posts like, “Help! I got rejected everywhere!” Those are always from students who discovered CC after they had completed their application process.
I just read the article. It made me sad that only the bad responses to posts were focused on. I’ll admit that I don’t usually respond to chances threads, but sometimes useful information about what to focus on in essays, whether to interview etc can come from them.
I love how ignorant most of the country is when it comes to admissions. The article acts as if 6 (count em, 6) AP classes, a 3.8, and top 20% are sure-fire signs of an acceptance letter at MIT. Right.
Its lovely how mean people can be when they have the benefit of anonymity. Its not really a surprise that BeefSupreme would decline to give his name out. He would never dare to make a comment such as that if recognized by his real name. The realism is not necessarily in debate (as I think he was right considering the races of both applicants), but he obviously derives enjoyment from sounding excessively mean and arrogant, which makes his comments unnecessary. Its kind of pathetic, in honesty, that he couldn’t state something without trying to pretend he is better than everyone else, but I guess that some people can’t maturely handle acceptances to top colleges. I’m sure he’ll improve sometime soon.
Edit: To clarify, yes, I likewise think their chances aren’t great. There isn’t any need to phrase it so rudely.
Exactly, that is my point. He will say things on the internet he would never say in real life, something easily indicated by his reluctance to disclose his real name.
Well, I gotta agree that the chance threads are brutal. I remember someone posted great stats, and the only response was, “sorry. nothing special about you. no offense”
^I agree. Oh, Beef. This article actually made me feel even more ashamed of myself for wasting my time on futile efforts to assure myself via CC comments. CC’s a drug, people, save yourselves!!!
in reality, i like getting to see whats out there. if i wasnt on CC, i would have no idea who im competing against, and what the top of the applicant pool likes like.
Beef was harsh, but correct. None of those people really had much of a shot at their schools, like many have said - the journalists clearly don’t understand how difficult it is to get into a top tiered school. Better a reality check, then blissfully applying to all the ivies, thinking “Oh, my teacher said I’m her best student, I’m sure to get into all of them!”
CC taught me a lot about the college admissions process, and I’m grateful for that. I had no idea the competition I was up against, and it was a great reality check. And if someone is going to get emotionally wounded by an anonymous web comment about if they can make it into a college, then maybe they have other things they should be focusing on.