To begin, my list is as follows: Williams, Middlebury, Bowdoin, Amherst, Kenyon, Davidson, Dartmouth. This is pretty tentative, though I am happy with it. I have a couple of concerns and any help would be much appreciated.
Will Dartmouth give me the same small-LAC experience as a Williams, Middlebury, Bowdoin etc...?
Should I add any other schools to my list? I do want to retain the small class sizes and close relationships with my teachers, but beyond that I do not have many restrictions.
I currently have a 33 on the ACT. I am planning on taking it again, even if only for piece of mind. How competitive is that? I have pretty solid extracurriculars and grades. I will have greats recs. I am white...
Your lists consists of schools that are pretty much reaches for everyone. The top schools can fill up many times over with students with amazing stats, recommendations, ECs etc. I suggest that you develop a more far-reaching application list to include those reach schools and also some schools that are more of a match as well as some safety schools that are affordable and that you would be happy to attend.
Safeties might include: Wooster, Earlham, Kalamazoo. Matches include Denison, Dickinson, F&M, Trinity in Hartford, CT. Schools with holistic admission, small class size, which value fit – such as OP’s original list – are reaches for everyone.