listing varsity and club sport on common app

Context: I was on a varsity sports team for freshman year and sophomore year, and we got a bunch of awards at the state level. I stupidly overloaded on honors/AP classes junior year, so I had to quit to maintain my GPA (and my sanity lmao). However, I still wanted to play the sport, so I just joined the local club.

tl;dr If you play 2 years on varsity and 2 years on club (same sport), how would you list that on the common app? Would you click on “other” in the dropdown box, list the sport, and then explain the situation?