The above list varies greatly in terms of feel – Berry being for example more religious and Sarah Lawrence being almost the polar opposite. Definitely check the feel. Also use the website niche to get the student’s nutshell summary of how they view their own campuses.
She may want to consider Mt. Holyoke or Smith – they are not in a city but are in or near Northampton. Great art, real campuses, no Greek presence and they take transfers. Of the two, Mt. H is more homey and less competitive, but both are nice schools. If she’s attending one school, she can attend any of five schools – also includes Hampshire, Amherst and UMass amherst.
She may also want to consider Mills in the Bay Area – it has all of her wants. I know an art major there who is very happy. Mills allows cross reg at Berkeley and also an art school.
Vassar – checks all of her boxes but takes few transfers – is in a suburban part of a small city and is on the commuter train line to NYC
Bard – even more arty than VAssar, and on Amtrak line to NYC, takes transfers
She should also consider Wesleyan --takes transfers, is in a large town, and has access to NYC sort of. It’s not direct by any means, unlike Vassar. Wesleyan has Greek life but isn’t dominated by it
Connecticut College is in New London and no Greek life
Barnard – she could transfer in but their FA for transfers is terrible usually. In a “quiet” part of Manhattan in that it’s where there’s relatively more green area. It has a defined campus and is across the street from Columbia and its defined campus.
Sarah Lawrence – checks all of her boxes, very arty, 20 minutes outside of NYC,
Simmons in Boston may give great merit, it’s part of a consortium with an art school
Wellesley might be nice but it’s transfer-in rate is super low.
Ithaca – very arty and checks all of her boxes.
Muhlenberg – very arty and in small City – lots of NYC kids go there, theater, jazz, writing
Haverford / Bryn Mawr might be great, but their transfer-in rate is not huge. Otherwise the pair check her boxes
Earlham is arty and in a smally city, very nice school.
Centre College
St. Olaf is arty and 40 miles outside of Minneapolis. They run buses into the City. Lovely school.
Tufts has the museum program. Very nice school