What is your estimated total student loan debt after 4 and 5 years at this Jesuit College? How will this debt impact your “career choices” post graduation? Your college advisor might be on target about prioritizing course load/selection, honor’s college and time to graduate (speaking from experience).
Instead of majoring in psychology, have you given any thought to become a Psychiatric–Mental Health Nurse Practitioner instead (if mental health counseling is your goal)? Much higher pay, autonomy, job demand and job satisfaction IMHO.