<p>Personally I’d lean toward IU-Kelley. I think IU is an under-appreciated gem in a fun college town. There is certainly something to be said for the Big 10 sports experiences (I know, I know, the football team does stink, but basketball is very good). With your stats I think you’ll qualify for pre-admit to Kelley as well as some automatic merit scholarships. Check the web sites for both.</p>
<p>Check the placement office data for both schools and see if you can get feedback about where geographically they are strongest. I think Kelley brings more weight than Miami (OH) and seems to have strong connections for jobs in Chicago (as well as the obvious Indianapolis strength). When I worked in Chicago we saw a lot of UIUC, Indiana-Kelley and Notre Dame grads for interviews. I don’t recall any Miami (OH) grads, but that’s just one data point.</p>