I agree that Geneseo is quite a pretty village. I go to my orthodontist there! Another thing though as I’ve seen passing through the college campus is the amount of hills that I would have to walk up on the way to campus. Pair that with the fact that they don’t necessarily have what I want in regards to classes, and Geneseo is pretty low on my list.
And I’ve looked at almost all the SUNYs (including Binghamton, Buffalo and Stonybrook) and I’ve narrowed them out in some way or another. Stonybrook is out because I feel that it’s a bit too far away, and I forget the reasons Binghamton and Buffalo were out, but it was probably having to do with not having quite what I wanted major-wise.