HPU is not well-thought of by the people who know it, and not well-known otherwise.
Pace is good if you want preprofessional education but you won’t have a traditional campus life at all. Baruch is much cheaper and offers a similar experience for a similar academic level.
UMW is a solid choice. If you like it, why not apply to SUNY Geneseo and UNC-Wilmington? (Based on what you said about the South, UNC-Wilmington would have the advantage of being in the South, plus it’s near a beach like Flagler.)
If you want Florida and AACSB-accredited, what about Rollins?
I hope you applied to UConn!
Can you tell us:
cost of attendance - (scholarships and grants) = …?
for each university?