Eckerd - excellent for creative writing, good for B/B+ students (or lopsided students), “Writers’ retreat” led for example by Dennis Lehane. A good match.
Denison as a reach - their creative non fiction writing concentration is excellent. They’re test optional if her Math+English scores are well below 1300 together.
Ithaca - Good for B+ students, can be test optional if total score is below 1200.
Kalamazoo - Good for serious B+ students, can be test optional is score is below 1200.
Wooster - Good for serious B+/A- students who are strong writers, can be test optional if score is below 1200.
Knox - Good for B students, very strong for writing, can be test optional if score is below 1100.
Susquehanna - Good for B students, very friendly and supportive, can be test optional.
Check out UPuget Sound, Willamette, Beloit, Roanoke, Wheaton MA, Augustana IL, Chatham, SUNY Oswego, SUNY Geneseo (reach).