<p>maudelebowski and actingbug…</p>
<p>I am not on any type of witchhunt in any shape or form! </p>
<p>My questions are for two reasons. The first reason is that I am a college counselor who advises applicants to college theater programs. I had not heard of this program and was reading this thread along with everyone else. Questions arose for me after reading various posts and I assumed since the admissions director for this program was participating, and offered to answer any questions posed of him, I would learn more so that I could understand this school and become more familiar with it as the nature of my job is such that I recommend colleges and theater programs to prospective students. I read many threads on CC to learn of programs and people’s experiences at them to inform myself so that I can guide students in their college selections. I had no idea that the types of questions I asked which are TYPICAL QUESTIONS asked of any college theater program would be an issue for a college rep to answer. It’s funny but I just sent off a list of questions to one of my juniors that he should ask at theater departments on his college visits and in his exploration of schools. The questions I asked here are the kinds of things that prospective families SHOULD ask. </p>
<p>How are those a witch hunt and how am I showing off? I am relating what I know about college admissions since the rep from this school first assumed that I, and/or others, did not understand how the process works. I mentioned where I was coming from to give some perspective that I have some clue as to how admissions works as not only do I have a graduate degree in Education, have taught at five colleges, have been the parent of two college graduates (including a BFA in Drama student), and am a college counselor who advises students and their families on college admissions, including to theater programs. Not everyone on CC is new to the college process and I could see that this member is NEW TO CC and likely did not realize that and so I pointed that out and not to “show off”. Anyone who has been on the Musical Theater or Theater Majors Forum or other forums on CC for some time, know who I am (just look at my post count that is just since Aug., 2004 when the post counts started new but I have actually been on CC since the summer of 2002, a total of seven years). </p>
<p>The second reason I was asking questions for clarification as I did not understand the information that the adcom was sharing here…is because I care about CC and the information that is on these message boards and that it be accurate since a huge number of people visit these forums to gather information. And so as much clarity as possible would benefit all who read here and want to learn about this program (and others). I was asking on behalf of all who were reading the thread. I was not the only one confused, either.</p>
<p>I have nothing against this program/school/conservatory as I had never heard of it until I had read this thread. I wanted to learn more and understand what I was reading. I am not picking on this school whatsoever. Had it been about ANY other school and I had read similar posts, I would be asking similar questions! And we have an adcom here and so I thought I would get the real information from the horse’s mouth, as they say. The answers are not that forthcoming. I think it is the answers themselves that are hurting the school on this thread, NOT the questions. The questions are questions that are asked on CC ALL THE TIME about ALL programs. However, we tend to be able to get this information readily about almost all other programs. I did not know these were trick questions or witch hunt questions. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Ya see, my “endless questions” are due to the statements that have been made that are NOT TRUE and thus, I asked for clarification as they appear misleading. The admissions director stated that 180 are ACCEPTED. The website says that 180 are ACCEPTED. That is impossible if they have 180 slots available. Why would a school make it sound like out of 4000 applicants, that only 180 are accepted? You are right. OF COURSE THEY ACCEPT MORE THAN 180! But why would the website and admissions director state they ONLY accept 180??? It is misleading. I have never seen another school do this. The school’s website says that 5% are admitted. That can’t possibly be true. The way you state an acceptance rate is you take how many applied (not how many were seen at festivals and conventions) and how many were admitted. But what NYCDA seems to be doing, if I am following the posts and website correctly, is saying how many were seen at conventions, festivals and other individual auditions (4000) and then using the YIELD (180) which is not the same as the number ACCEPTED, to state an acceptance rate. This is not how it is done. </p>
<p>I don’t understand what I am showing off. I care about the readers on CC and that they get accurate information. Some are new to college admissions and so need to understand what it is they are reading here. CC has threads that list how many apply and how many are accepted and how many enroll at many theater programs. I could not safely state if NYCDA were to be added to such a list (or even in materials I send my clients) that they have a 5% acceptance rate and that 4000 apply and only 180 are accepted even though the admissions director here implied those figures. </p>
<p>It would be REALLY great if we could all get the correct information. Otherwise, I believe the posts by the reps hurt, rather than help. I was really eager to learn more about this program as I have occasionally had students who have considered two year programs and I don’t know enough about NYCDA to recommend it to them and I know even LESS now that this thread has such unclear information on it.</p>