@bluebayou I don’t believe @NotVerySmart was referring to a student who makes $150k immediately after school. Instead, they were talking about someone who leaves college, makes less than $50k a year, and is encouraged to stay in the state for the benefits. Eventually, they work their way up to the top 5% income bracket and pay quite a bit of money back into NY, where they might not have stayed if not for the existence of this program.