Well, I think Northwestern University may have valid questions they’re bringing up regarding the highly popular USNWR rankings & methodology. However, US News does seem to take great pains to accurately assess and report their data. I’m not saying the data analysts at US News never make errors …and if so, I’m sure it is no doubt unintentional!
But Northwestern University’s published criticisms are concerning because I’m not sure I entirely agree with their stance on this issue and how it impacts the university. For instance, Northwestern reports that they meet 100% demonstrated need for all successful applicants, but I’ve heard from a relative and others information to the contrary.
Still, it’s a valuable discussion to have on College & University Rankings because it helps everyone to do their own homework (i.e., comparisons) between the institutions their S or D is interested in possibly attending & what those places report about their institutions of higher ed.