For an artsy student I think UNC Asheville would be an excellent choice. Because it’s located in an artist town (with a revitalized downtown used an example for urban planners on the US) and the liberal arts colleges tend to attract more ‘intellectual’ students, I think it’s be an excellent choice. It’s also known as NC 's public LAC. A 3.8 + high LSAT would not hinder any goal of yours.
Unc Wilmington is more of a traditional college experience, with a greater variety of majors, especially business and education which are really good, but more preprofessional.
Did you get into the honors college at either one? If not, contact the people in charge and see if you can apply. Love if learning is much appreciated at honors college, especially live if reading, and ballet shows you know time management + commitment.