Reed could be a good option for you. Relative to other LACs, it is a top contender in the “least sporty” and “coolest urban environment” categories. Some qualifications:
- While Reed is not "sporty" in the traditional sense, it does have a significant PE requirement. On the other hand, since Reed does not have to pay for NCAA athletics, they can afford a wide variety of unusual and appealing PE options. http://www.reed.edu/sports_center/pe-requirement/classes.html
- While Reed is in Portland city limits, the immediate surroundings lack urban excitement. Reed is located in a relatively affluent and safe residential neighborhood, including an undeveloped on-campus canyon with a surprising amount of wildlife. You have to travel to reach the cool parts of the city, but this is not difficult, because Portland is bike-friendly and has excellent public transportation.
- While many LACs (especially in the Northeast) are preppy, Reed is hipster. If you are from the Northeast, you may think that schools like Wesleyan, Vassar, or Brown are hipster. If so, you will need to recalibrate for the Pacific Northwest. If you are more comfortable in a preppy atmosphere, Reed might not be the best choice.
- Reed has the longest "reach" of any college in the 48 states; the average Reed student is nearly 1,400 miles from home. So there is a lot of geographic diversity on campus. However, it is always harder to recruit long-distance students; most students want to stay within about 300 miles of home (i.e. an easy one-day drive). So by top LAC standards, Reed has a relatively low yield and an unusually high acceptance rate (about 31% for Fall 2016). So statistically, your chances of admissions could be good. https://ink.niche.com/top-25-colleges-students-farthest-home/