NYU test submission

I’m debating if I should send in my ACT score or my 3 AP Exams. I am planning on applying ED1 to CAS and major in History.
ACT Breakdown:
Reading:35
English: 26
Math: 28
Science: 26
Composite:29

AP Scores;
Psych, Environmental Science, US History (all 4s)

Which one would better my chances?

I think your AP scores show your strength better than your ACT, and your 29 is on the lower end of typically admitted students, but perhaps the committee will note your 35 in Reading, which really aligns with your history major. Also, your 4s on the AP tests, specifically history, show your strength in a way that makes sense for your major. I would choose the AP scores.