The Wilmington case is an interesting one–I think it’s obvious that the professor is a creep, but that his statement about the student is protected speech, which means that a public university can’t punish him for publishing it. But you can see, once again, the clever efforts to find some argument for punishing him. It is sad to see a person using the First Amendment as a shield for such jerky behavior, but that’s part of the price we pay for freedom of speech.