LuxLake, if Eckerd remains on the list, try to see if she can attend one of the accepted student weekends with you or your spouse. They do an excellent job and answer any questions.
With this “opinionated” requirement, your daughter will probably only be suitable for and comfortable at Harvard, Columbia and the other 4,873 colleges in the United States whose faculty (mostly the product of the spend-other-people’s money and the “me” decades) are wholly and irredeemably liberal. Don’t worry about “toning down” anything. Really, outside of a few Christian colleges, she could walk on to campus at any university in America – really, any and all – and immediately find the “liberal environment” she craves – all without breaking a sweat.