@benjima totally !
34 ACT - only took it one time, I don’t believe they superscore the ACT
SAT Subject Tests: Math Level 2: 760, US History: 750
Increasing leadership roles on the Debate Team
National Speech & Debate Association Academic All American
National Speech & Debate Outstanding Distinction
Nationally ranked in the top 20 by the National Speech and Debate Association
National Merit Commended Scholar
National Hispanic Scholar
AP Scholar with Distinction
About 600 hours volunteering and doing a service project with the same organization
Also very involved with theater - Acting and tech
Hispanic Scholarship Fund - Youth Leadership Institute at the University of Pennsylvania this past summer - that is when I fell in love with Penn!
But no PEEP! Still going to ED though, got to give it a shot!
Good luck to you all!
@benjima also got accepted! i love the idea of a chat 
Those are stellar stats.
IMO the reason you may have not been selected could have been that the incremental value to you (given your PENN summer leadership activities)
would have been much smaller as compared to an alternate, also well qualified, candidate with no prior Penn experience.
PEEP gives high achieving seniors the opportunity to gain exposure to Penn and give them a sense of the incredible resources and opportunities available to Penn students. You already have gained this exposure with your summer leadership activities.
In any case, you should definitely not be discouraged and proceed to apply to Penn per your original plan.
@Volunteerism thanks.