<p>@wilde12 All of these schools are good schools, and you have the stats to be a competitive applicant at each of these universities. If I were in your positions, I would evaluate the environment (location, surrounding city, diversity of students, etc). You have a good mix from a cornfield (Notre Dame) to a huge city (NYU) so it ultimately ends up being your choice. Since these schools all have a good reputation and are bound to have your interests to study, I suggest you focus less on reputation and more on a gut feeling. Do some research on the schools and try to get a feel for their environment. Once you have narrowed it down, apply and from there where ever you get accepted go an visit before making your final choice.
Good luck</p>