Please help! Is this a decent topic???

<p>Here's the prompt. It's for UT Austin:
Describe a setting in which you have collaborated or interacted with people whose experiences and/or beliefs differ from yours. Address your initial feelings and how those feelings were or were not changed by this experience.</p>

<p>This is my first post, and I'm really nervous. This is my first draft, I just wrote it. It's in no way finished. Please just read it and tell me if the subject and topic would work or if I should go another route. This isn't for you to look at spelling and grammar, I want to know if this is a good essay topic. Thanks so much!!!!</p>

<pre><code>CLANG! The torn synthetic leather ball tears through the iron rim and spreads the chain linked net. Not SWISH. Not a pretty, air conditioned, clean sound. CLANG! A raw, dirty, angry noise heard across the court. This isn’t playing on freshly waxed maple wood, this is grinding on rough concrete, splattered with graffiti and sweat. When you fall in a gym, you slide around a little, pull yourself up and keep going. When you fall here, your knees stain in a gushing crimson color. You won’t get a varsity letter jacket here. In fact, you’ll be lucky to get respect. This is a different game, a game I fought to learn and play.
For someone who loves the game of basketball as much as I do, I used to have a lot of trouble finding games. That all changed when I visited my local park a few months ago. This park is absolute simplicity. Two basketball hoops, a couple picnic tables, and a water fountain. And the people. Slouching, messy facial hair and torn t-shirts. Carrying nothing but cigarettes, anger, and distrust. At this point, most of my friends would be a little nervous, wary, or uncomfortable. I guess I’d feel all that too, if I wasn’t 6’4” with shoes on, in an area where the average height is 5’7”.
</code></pre>

<p>Another thing about my height: I’m naturally good at basketball. It comes with the long arms. So, you can imagine my frustration and disappointment when I wasn’t picked up on a team. So as I sat there, watching the teams sprinting down the court, I decided to get to know some people. Being as confident as I am, I sit down next to a man with tattoos all over his hands and neck, introduce myself, and offer him a handshake and a smile. He glares back, takes a hit of his cigarette, and says to a friend: “The *****..?” He proceeds to cuss me out in spanish, and laugh with another rough looking character sipping out of a bottle. Did I do something wrong? I just want to play basketball. So what’s the deal?
This treatment continued for weeks. Eventually however, they slowly began to accept me. It was at this point I learned that all the animosity came from my skin color.
“Look at this white boy, with his car, coming into our park and trying to hoop with us!”
When asked where I lived, I dodged the question with vague descriptions.
“You know that neighborhood over on the east? Yeah I live in there...”
“You mean the country club? You rich white boy. Shouldn’t you be playing golf or something?”
While most people would take offense to this, I shook it off. I’d heard it all before. Being half white and half mexican, it can be hard to fit in. To one group of kids, you’re not important enough. You don’t hunt, or own a ranch, and your daddy isn’t the mayor. And to another, you’re spoiled. You’re too lucky, you have a dad, you can buy whatever you want. While neither of these opinions are completely true, it’s something I deal with regularly. After all, I’m really grateful for everything I had. But I learned another meaning of grateful that day.
That night, I headed home at around 8:30 pm. I usually stay out until 10 or 11, but the next day I had the SAT. Just as I’m walking out, Santos, my only friend there, asks why I’m going so early. I explain I have the SAT and I want to get plenty of sleep. Guess what he tells me?
“Wow, good luck. I wanted to go to college, but I had to get a job to take care of my family.”
The sad thing is, most of these people agree with that statement. Either in their young 20s or just graduated, out of about 15 people, only 2 are enrolled in community college. In my family, I was always going to go to college. It was just the plan. My mom told me before I could read how great a life I will have because of college. And these guys..the guys I judged, and criticized, the “ghetto people” I played with... these guys never had a chance. It’s not that they didn’t want to go to college. They couldn’t.
I still go there, and I play basketball. Whenever I invite a friend, they get nervous, and uncomfortable in that environment. And I understand. But I don’t agree. Because to them, they’re losers who don’t care about their lives. But to me, they’re people, just like me. People, who didn’t get a chance.</p>

<p>I think it is a very good topic and experience which is responsive to the question asked. To improve this essay, it needs to have more of you and your personal feeling thoughts and expectations incorporated into it with some emphasis on whether you changed your views and feelings as you continued to play there… Some questions that could guide you in your re.writing…Why did you go there? How old we’re you ? We’re you somewhat afraid,nervous …what were your expectations when you went ? How did the silent treatment…mild rejection make you feel…what happened when you got on the court? Did you gain the trust and acceptance of some of the players over time? Did your feelings and attitudes toward the players change as you began to play.<br>
I hope this helps …you have the makings of a good essay here…what will make it more interesting is if you tell us a little more about yourself and your feelings in this essay.</p>

<p>you have a good start, but add more about you! who you are, how you felt, where you come from etc.</p>

<p>Thank you guys! I’m glad at least my topic will work!</p>

<p>Your welcome …look forward to the re.write telling us more about you and basketball and your basketball/cultural encounter.</p>

<p>It’s not a good idea to post your full draft on a public message board. You’d be better off describing it or allowing people to read it via a private message.</p>

<p>I was just thinking that actually :confused:
Can I take it down?</p>