I am done with the college admissions process, and currently choosing a program. Both Georgetown and Emory have dual degree programs for physics and engineering at Columbia and GaTech. I am so crossed with the two because on one hand Columbia seems to be better than GaTech for engineering considering networking and research opportunities. But, it seems Emory offers more for the particular areas of physics I am interested in: Astronomy and Astrophysics. While Georgetown seemed to focus on physics of matter. Could anyone here give me an holistic comparison of the two? Which one do you think would be best especially considering I want to eventually study something in the area of astrophysics and engineering? Is Columbia better than GaTech for engineering?
I’ll start with the last question. While some are comparable, no school is better than GaTech for engineering. Now for the main issue. I vote for neither. These 3/2 dual degree programs are a marketing gimmick for schools that don’t have engineering to say they do. It is rare to actually complete both programs. You will more than likely want to stay with your first school for the 4th year, or might not even be admitted to the second school. You’re also paying for 5 years of school without corresponding value. Pick one undergrad and stay with it, perhaps moving on for a masters if desired. That said, from a purely academic standpoint (not considering cost, fit, etc.), I would choose Emory. It is a stronger school in the sciences than Georgetown, and allows you to take some classes at nearby GaTech if desired.
I went to Emory undergrad and loved it. I am now looking at schools with my son. From a purely social perspective, I would chose Emory/Georgia Tech because of the proximity of campuses. I hope that you’ll have as positive experience in college as I did–at whatever school you choose. If I had had to leave campus after my junior year, it would have tough. With the Emory/GaTech program, you could get an apartment between the campuses and be able to continue to see your Emory friends on a regular basis. I realize that “Columbia” is an Ivy League, but from my understanding from several CEO’s the name of the institution matters much less for engineers than it does for liberal arts majors.
I agree with LTLurker, it’s a huge plus to be able to stay with the same group of friends for 4 or 5 years. You’ll also be able to take class at Tech, while enrolled at Emory, and take classes at Emory, while enrolled at Tech.
It also gives you the option of staying with Emory and completing your BS, and then going to grad school (for engineering or physics) at Tech or any other school.