And a private school known for its rigor should have strong college counselors who can guide you through these questions, help you streamline this multi-piece story and support you in their school report.
Over the course of 4 or 5 threads, no one here has enough info about your school targets, location, or scores, to advise. And as we often say on CC, simply falling into the mid-range of scores for a highly competitive college is not enough. Many of the kids with lower scores may be recruited athletes, kids with some strong connection to the college, etc. Nor is a non-profit a tip, many kids do that.
At this point, so much is speculative.