I think several of these have good quality programs. As an engineer for many years, I have never worked with or heard of anyone coming from Miami-Ohio - and I work with a lot of Midwestern engineers. Maybe it’s a hidden gem that I haven’t been aware of. It sounds like a really nice school in general, But, I am in the dark as far as the engineering program goes. My sense is Pitt and Villanova are pretty similar in quality. Each has their strengths. I believe Pitt’s Biomedical Engineering is excellent - that’s why I asked the question. I can’t comment on the other schools.
I would look at the Career centers and placement, grad school placement, and also if there are any issues actually declaring your major (are there limits on enrollment?).