<p>2100hopes, your argument is interesting if not particularly novel. Here's the basic problem I see with it... I don't think I'd rely on CC forum members as a statistically valid population to represent college applicants in general. They're self-selected and self-reported, and any forum has its share of trolls.</p>
<p>I do think a convincing case has been made that highly selective colleges consider the whole application over its parts, but I wouldn't counsel anyone aiming that high to submit an application with, say, test scores that are at the bottom end of the current median range for their target school. Especially test scores since, out of all parts of the application, they probably require the least investment of time and/or money to improve.</p>