“Do you have any recommendations for safety schools? I was thinking maybe something in the NESCAC”
Your SAT score (CR + M) puts you above the 75th percentile at Colby, Bates, Connecticut College and Trinity (and within the middle 50% at the other seven NESCACs.) Any of these four schools would be reasonably safe for you, as would the Patriot League’s Colgate. Hamilton (NESCAC) could be a match for you; as at your other schools, your chances there would increase greatly if you were recruited for swimming.