<p>if you can relax your geographical limits, a school with good merit aid, strong science (including premed), and apparently very pretty girls is St Olaf (well, if you like girls to be tall and blond). It’s in Minnesota. Same thing but southern, with strong connections to hospitals: Rhodes College, in Tennessee.
Within your geographic limits, but no idea on the “girl prettiness” scale, you have Dickinson College. Strong in the sciences, in Pennsylvania, merit aid.
For all three, go to their website and fill out the “request information” form right away. They know they are “top tier backups” and don’t like to feel like a safety. So, “expressing interest” would go a long way to keep you from the waitlist.
In NYS, Geneseo would be a safety.
Hobart&William Smith but not sure how strong it is in math&science for someone with your profile.
In Ohio, Wooster or if sports matter to you, tOSU. In PA, Pitt (you’d be competitive for their Honors college). </p>