Only $9000/year in tuition is definitely attractive. It’s clearly not a college that you’d want to attend if you wanted a wide variety of options in terms of majors. Nor would you want to go there if you’re not ok with taking a year of Greek and a year of Hebrew. And if you have problems with the idea of taking mandated general ed classes that include Christian topics, then you wouldn’t want to go there either.
But it’s a free country. And there are thousands of other universities and colleges for one to choose from across the US. Some are religious schools and some are not. Some are very conservative, like this one appears to be (based on what the school has posted on their website…I read all of their stuff on the “Standard” part of their website).
If it doesn’t float your boat, then don’t apply and don’t attend.
The head of the school seems to be very accomplished. He has an impressive resume, regardless of the particular religious faith he practices.