<p>I disagree with your guidance counselor. There is nothing wrong with applying ED to a reach school. But you must go in knowing it is a bit of a long shot and be prepared to move on if it doesn’t work out. Have other good options in mind, interview with some other schools, and have other applications ready to go just in case. I would apply to a couple of match/safety schools that are rolling or non-binding EA so you should get an acceptance or two in December.</p>
<p>If Brandeis is your top choice, be sure you have “demonstrated interest” through a campus visit, interview, maybe see if you can shadow a student for a day or whatever else works.</p>