Should I apply to Swarthmore for transfer (Econ) instead of NYU Stern (Finance) ?

@“Erin’s Dad”

Yesterday I was looking through the 2015-2016 CDS for most of the schools on my list and based on their overall transfer selectivity I’d say the reach schools on my list are:
NEU: 36.18%
NYU: 27.65%
Villanova: 38.51%
Clark: 38.72%

That being said, for some of these the business school selectivity for transfer may be higher or (in stern’s case) lower