should i talk about the same topic in two different essays?

for my common app essay i did the one dealing with something so meaningful that my application would not be complete without it and talked about my musical background.
for one of the umich supplemental essays i want to talk about the same thing for the essay about what community i belong in and my role in it.
i’m probably gonna do this for many other supplemental essays as well, but i don’t know if colleges would care about two essays having the same topic in it. should i go through with what i originally intended or vary my topic for each individual essay?

I think that having 2 essays is a great opportunity to highlight 2 different aspects of who you are.

Recycling the same topic eliminates that wonderful opportunity.

I would choose a different topic.