<p>Also in Indiana, Hanover might be a good choice. Do a search in the parents section for keyword Hanover and you'll find some positive reviews about visits there from Curmudgeon and I think Doddsdad.</p>
<p>Although it has been mentioned already, I would suggest your daughter take a very hard look at Davidson. It is an elite LAC on par witrh the best in the North East, Christian and has a very strong year abroad program. Given your daughter's excellent school record, Davidson should be a very good fit. The other school in the South I would look at for a first class Liberal Arts education with a Christian flavour is Sewanee-university of the South. Not quite the reputation of Davidson but an outstanding school for somebody with literary, musical and religious interests.</p>