@Beaudreau, thanks for the link! I completely agree that certain conservative activities reduce a student’s admission chances at some schools! I guess the flip side is that the students might not be happy anyway at such a place. Maybe it happens the other way around as well - where more “liberal” activities can hurt acceptance chances, but maybe that would only be at a religious university. I’ve never heard of it happening though.
A&M is pretty conservative, so it seems that Eagle Scout rank, Boys and Girls State, ROTC, etc. are given appropriate consideration.
My son wrote an essay that was probably well received at A&M, but he used the same essay for other applications. We mentioned to him that it might not be well received in other cases, but he stuck with it.