I can’t speak for undergrads, but I am a graduate student at Fordham in their English department working on my M.A., and I’ve had nothing but good experiences there thus far.
The two main campuses are way different. I take classes at both of them. Lincoln Center is basically a skyscraper set up like a high school; the plus for LC is that it’s right off Columbus Circle, two blocks from Central Park, right down the street from Lincoln Center and Juilliard, etc.
Rose Hill, the main campus in the Bronx, looks like a classic university, with Gothic stone buildings and Catholic iconography on the grounds. It may be the prettiest campus I’ve ever set foot on in my life. The surrounding area gets a bad rap, I think. I live south of the campus in Belmont, where a lot of Fordham students live. It’s an ethnic neighborhood with a lot of Albanians, Dominicans, Mexicans, and Italians. The neighborhood has a definite communal feel, and the residents are all nice.
I may be taking this for granted being that I’m a 6’2", 25 year old male, but I’ve walked from the subway about a mile up Fordham Road to my apartment at 1am, when it’s a dead zone, and never encountered trouble. I suppose this could be different if you’re younger, female, physically smaller—but maybe not. If you’re aware of your surroundings, there’s not much to worry about. I’ve walked around Belmont at varying hours of the night and never once been scared of anyone or anything.
Then again, if you’ve spent your whole life in ultra-white Connecticut or the Pennsylvania suburbs (which seems the case for many Fordham kids), then the Bronx is going to be culture shock no matter what. You’ll adjust.
In terms of reputation and rigor, it kind of depends on who you ask. I work as a graduate assistant in the business school, and through doing that, I can say that most of the incoming freshmen are quite bright. As far as reputation goes, it depends who you ask. My uncle, who graduated from Lewis & Clark, considers Fordham to be “just under Ivy league,” although I don’t know if that’s really true. I know it’s a respected school, especially in the liberal arts/humanities, which is part of why I decided to go here. I know that in most all ranks of NYC colleges, it almost always goes:
- Columbia
- NYU
- Fordham
- Pace, Hunter, St. Johns, Hofstra, etc. etc.
Based on that, I’d say Fordham is pretty good.