@NYYFanNowMTdad I think being ready to/wanting to audition in the fall really depends on the student. Some feel ready to go, and others want a little more time to prepare. The pros of fall auditions are probably spreading out the auditions over a longer period of time, possibly getting an early acceptance or two that can relieve the pressure and maybe adjust the overall list, getting some of the audition nerves out early before the bulk of auditions in the spring… the cons probably are auditioning before the student really feels 100% ready, getting nos to fall auditions that rock confidence.
I am sure there are other pros and cons that are individual to each student and family.
I can only speak for where I teach… we attend Moonifieds and Virginia Theatre Auditions (VTA), and have a November on campus audition date in the fall. Moonifieds and on campus auditions are full auditions, and we accept, deny, and defer the decision until we have completed auditions in February from those two auditions. So, it can be a great way for a student to know where they stand.
VTA is a combined audition, and this gives students a chance to test audition material, receive feedback, and talk to us (and other schools). We still require an on campus, NYC, or video full audition/interview for those we see at VTA. I think other schools use VTA similarly, and I think some use the Mid-Atlantic auditions that way, so it could be an opportunity to try material without the stakes being as high? Although, I have not attended, so I am not 100% sure. I have not attended CAP, so I am not sure of that format.