<p>Perhaps they are giving out two different sets of responses depending on the manner in which each person asks about the email debacle. </p>
<p>For instance, when an applicant says “I received this email… What does it mean?”, they’ll answer “Congratulations! You’re accepted.” (I, too, called and the response was “The email was an unofficial notification of acceptance. Congratulations.”)</p>
<p>But, if an applicant says “I’ve heard about NYU sending out emails,” they’ll answer “it was done randomly, so wait for the official response on April 1st.” This was the way ReMu answered to a girl on its Facebook fanpage when she said “I know about this email, but I didn’t get one.” </p>
<p>Like somebody said earlier, I don’t think the largest private higher education institution in the United States would do anything “randomly.” The response is most likely subjective to the person asking the question. </p>
<p>I wouldn’t be surprised if a same person calls twice, inquiring about the email in two different ways: “I got this email.” vs “I heard about it but didn’t get one.”, the response would be “Congratulations!” vs “Don’t worry, it was done randomly. You might still have a chance.”</p>