<p>Macalester–Reach
Colby–Reach
Colorado College–Match
NYU-Reach
Franklin and Marshall–Match
American–Match
Northeastern–Match
Ithaca College–Match to Slight Reach
UVM–Do you mean Vermont?–if so, then Match
UMass Amherst–Slight Reach</p>
<p>The problem in a nutshell is that you are a straight B student (and this is even with the honors/APs added in) applying for some top colleges (like Colby, NYU, and Macalester). Some of the other colleges on your list are more likely candidates, and I have indicated where you are likely to be accepted based upon this.</p>