OP, @dadof1 is a helpful poster with a D attending Rollins. I think she is very happy there. It’s a wonderful school in a beautiful location. He may be able to give you more insight on Rollins.
I second the suggestion upthread of Sewanee. Amazing English department, great professors, and moderate weather. Sewanee doesn’t meet full need for everyone, but they come very close (@94%). They tend to meet full need for students on lower and mid range of need. You’d also likely receive merit aid.