Travel to Wagner

Looking for information on traveling to Wagner - if flying in, is there one airport better than another? Is there public transportation from airport or better to rent a car? And hotel recommendations near Wagner would also be appreciated!

Thanks, fam!

We are flying into Laguardia and taking an uber to lower Manhatten to our hotel. Then we will take the Staten Island Ferry over to Wagner. We have also rented a car from LaGuardia and have stayed in Staten Island at the Holiday Inn Express in Staten Island.