<p>Madison is an intoxicating place. (I'm not talking about the drinking culture, although there is that.) The campus is breathtaking in its setting and architecture. The school spirit and cameraderis are astonishing. If you ever want proof, go to Madison on a football Saturday; get there early, wander around the city and campus, go to the game, then watch the crowd flow into the neighborhoods afterward. Do not do this if you have any aversion to the color red! And yet there are also many students and professors so immersed in their own worlds that they barely notice all that. The breadth and quality of academic choices is mind boggling. The City of Madison, which was always somewhat energized by the University and State government (it is the Capital of Wisconsin), but was otherwise a blue collar town in the middle of a farm area, has in the last thirty years evolved into a high tech/services economic powerhouse, virtually unrecognizable to those of us who remember the "Purina Pig Chow" commercials on local television back in our student days. I could go on and on. </p>
<p>But like every school, it's not right for everyone. In my own case, I started at a different public "commuter" school, then transferred to the UW for my junior year, excited to finally be hitting the "big time." After one semester I transferred back. It just wasn't right for me. I came from a school where everyone went to school, went to their job to pay for school, went home to sleep and then started over the next day, to a school where it seemed like everyone was partying on daddy's dime. That wasn't really true, but at that age, and coming from where I did, it seemed true. </p>
<p>But it wasn't as though I had a bad experience there; it just wasn't right for me. And when, five years later, I decided to go to professional school, I wound up back in Madison, much to my surprise. And this time I caught the vibe, had a much better time and a great experience.</p>
<p>Now, everything full cycle, I have a son entering his senior year of high school. It looks like he'll apply to three good midwestern LACs -- and the University of Wisconsin. And it's not out of the picture that despite his academic qualifications and our better economic ability he'll end up at that same "commuter" school I went to, because I know that its "fourth tier" ranking notwithstanding, it's actually an excellent university fully capable of doing as well by any kid willing to put in the effort as Wisconsin or Macalester or even the vaunted Ivies. (I've dealt with -- and in some cases fired -- enough Ivy Leaguers over the years to have long since lost any quaint notion that an Ivy League diploma somehow automatically confers brilliance or even competence.)</p>
<p>I don't know if Madison will be right for my son. I know it's a great school that is right for a lot of kids. All I can say is if it's on your child's list, go see it, because it is something to behold. I visit it often, and every time I get to State Street, and look up Bascom Hill, I still feel a little thrill.</p>