<p>par72 mentions Holy Cross frequently in cases like this-it's strong in the humanities and offers nice merit aid (including some $ for classics majors, I think). Bryn Mawr or some of the all-female colleges might be worth looking into, but I don't know if she'd go for that. What about Oberlin? It's in Ohio, but it fits most of the criteria. Haverford also might be worth considering.</p>