UC prompt 3.......Is my topic TOO open-ended?

Applying to College
1

Hi, I have already written my prompt 3 but after having someone from this board look it over, they told me it has nothing to do with the prompt. I thought prompt 3 is about anything, in my case its playing basketball and the relief i get from it.

Is this TOO open-ended? (I wrote another one just in case–that one being about my grandfather’s toughness and his death when I was young)

Which of the two should I go with and is their anyone willing to have a look at them?

Thanks

30 hours and counting till deadline…

2

<p>well from my understanding the rationale of the question states "This question seeks to give students the opportunity to share important aspects of their schooling or thier lives..." and if your essay about basketball is important to you then it fits the prompt~ perhaps ask the person who said it had nothing to do with the prompt WHY or WHICH part of the essay made it "stray"</p>