Have you ever thought why? Have your ever thought lack of information doesn’t help parents or incoming students?
do you even understand what Delta effect is? When difference is getting offset against each other, therefore net effect remains same? At time of admission 1st year, student may have different academic standings, but once you are admitted, your standing takes more or less normal ride, thus junior standing of last year would be expected to senior standing this year more or less same, it just doesn’t skew anymore drastically.
You still haven’t answered any of questions I had raised and that information is useful for potential applicants. UE has become a process that is being taken advantage and hurt lots of good students, because it is only applicable at time of application and most students fall into trap of picking a major. In my experience PREP students are more qualified than UE students and become victim of convoluted admission process.
To give you an example, 3 students are from same high school, have similar extra curriculum activities, .
Student A, higher GPA and higher ranking in school.
Student B, Lower GPA and lower ranking in school then student A.
Student C, Lowest GPA and lowest ranking among 3.
Student A and B are even buddies and did all sort of CS/CE related club activities together during their entire high school tenure.
Now student A has interest to CS/CompE so applies to CS 1st choice and ends up in PREP. (CompE is exclusive choice so can’t choose 2nd choice)
student B has interest in CompE, so applies to CompE and get into CompE.(CS is exclusive choice so can’t choose as 2nd choice)
student C applies to UE and get in to UE. (don’t remember what are options for 2nd choice as UE is exclusively 1st choice)
Now student A works hard to achieve all great results in both semesters successfully transfer to CS from PREP at end of 1st year.
Student B status quo with CompE.
Student C gets into CS at end of first semester from UE based on mere 3.25 GPA in 1st semester.
Student A is now acing in 2nd year CS and student C is struggling in 2nd year CS.
Student A is more qualified to be in CoE then student C, but because of convoluted admission process, right people ended up at wrong place and vice a versa. You can easily infer, who is student A, and I won’t disclosed student B and C identity. Sure your buddies won’t share this kind of info with you.
You are absolutely right, I have no personal interest with you or anyone here on board, but based on 2 kids college admission process experience in last 2 years, I have enough info to share with potential students that simply not being shared by admission advising office. As you claimed to have more info based on your narrow academic experience, you haven’t gone through the experience of PREP/Transfer students. By raising the awareness on the board here, potential candidates asked those questions to related authority and hopefully they share with them and make educated and informed decision. I don’t see any reason why UIUC is not doing that, there is no privacy violation or any such thing being asked.