<p>
[quote]
First of all, I said private sector as a whole, not just consulting. Your prescription is pitched to a fairly narrow subset of people that really want to get into consulting but can't get into a top 15 MBA program and yet can get into KSG.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>To your specific point regarding a top 15 MBA, I think your net is cast a bit too widely. The #15 MBA school is probably Cornell. It is rather debateable to me whether a Cornell MBA can really offer you as many opportunities in the private sector as a KSG MPA or MPP would. That seems like a toss-up to me. Again, whether we like it or not, Harvard is Harvard. That brand name and the alumni network are powerful portals of access. </p>
<p>Now, if you were talking M7, or perhaps top 10, I could probably get on-board. But top 15? I think that's pushing it. </p>
<p>
[quote]
And by the way, consulting is a very broad field. I doubt very much a KSG grad is getting opportunities to jump right into the exact management consulting opportunities at a place like McKinsey that let's say a Yale or Michigan MBA grad gets.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>Uh, why not? Speaking specifically about McKinsey, that is a firm that hires people from a wide range of disciplines and puts them in the same job as those with MBA's. I know people who have gotten master's degrees in technology & policy at MIT who have gotten the same associate jobs at McKinsey that the MBA's from both MIT and HBS have obtained. </p>
<p>But you don't have to take my word for it. You mentioned the Yale SOM, so let's compare that to KSG. About 15% of Yale MBA's enter consulting. That's highly comparable to the percentage of KSG master's students who enter consulting (public + private), averaged over all of the KSG master's programs, with figures ranging from a low of 5.5% for the KSG MPA/MC program to a whopping 30% (private + public consulting) from the KSG MPA2 program. Furthermore, the consulting salary figures for KSG are highly comparable to the consulting salary figures obtained by the Yale MBA's, which at first pass strongly indicates to me that these are comparable jobs with comparable responsibilities. </p>
<p><a href="http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/career/pdf/CS_placement06_FINAL.pdf%5B/url%5D">http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/career/pdf/CS_placement06_FINAL.pdf</a>
<a href="http://mba.yale.edu/careers/employment/pdf/careerreport.pdf%5B/url%5D">http://mba.yale.edu/careers/employment/pdf/careerreport.pdf</a></p>
<p>
[quote]
And KSG folks will probably do fine head-to-head against MBAs getting certain consulting jobs <strong><em>particularly if they already had good experience beforehand</em></strong> begging the question of your first assumption that you're talking about a subset of folks who could get into KSG but not a top 15 MBA program.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>There are indeed many people who can get into KSG but can't get into a top MBA program. Let's face it. MBA admissions are unpredictable and many people get rejected for arbitrary reasons. They are also somewhat uncorrelated (for example, I know people who got into HBS, Stanford GSB and the elite MIT LFM MBA+Master's in engineering program, but didn't get into Yale). Granted, KSG admissions are unpredictable also. But that's the point. Since the admissions to all of these programs are unpredictable, you will find people who will get into one but not the others. </p>
<p>
[quote]
Anyway, the KSG folks will not have nearly as good a footing to get jobs in marketing, operations, finance, etc. as folks from a top 15 MBA program. So, repeating what I said, if you want to maximize opportunities in the private sector, you'd be a fool to go to KSG.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>Again, while I disagree regarding your top 15 cutoff, nobody is disagreeing that a top MBA program will be more useful to get private sector jobs than would a KSG degree. But my point is, not everybody is going to get into a top MBA program. What should such a person do? Kill himself? If he can't get into a top MBA program but can get into KSG, that may be the best choice available to him. Honestly, what else is he going to do? </p>
<p>
[quote]
Well, certainly it does that for you. I am quite a bit more jaded. I am neither shocked nor awed by someone who went to Harvard, but I have met a whole lot of them.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>Oh, believe me, I am not talking about myself. Trust me when I say that I have far more reason to be jaded about Harvard than almost anybody else here. I won't get into why.</p>
<p>But that's not the point. The point is that the Harvard brand name does work. Maybe it shouldn't work. Heck, I often times think that it shouldn't work. But * it does work*, whether we like it or not. It is a brand name that will undoubtedly shock and awe the vast majority of people, whether they are Americans or foreigners. Like it or not, that is the truth. It does work. Harvard has a brand name that no other school can match. </p>
<p>But I think that, from a long-term perspective, what is even more valuable than the brand name are the alumni connections. Harvard, hands down, has the best connections of any school in the world. The fact is, many (probably most) good jobs in the world are obtained through social networks. </p>
<p>Besides, using your same argument, we shouldn't be impressed by anybody with a top MBA either, as after all, such a degree also doesn't tell us anything other than the person is fairly well educated, but may also be a prestige whore or be somebody who places a premium on what they think an MBA can do for them. The same logic applies. What's the difference? </p>
<p>
[quote]
It doesn't always work out that way, that the KSG brand name opens doors. You can ask one of my better friends who graduates from K-School recently and 6 months later is still temping and looking for a job.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>That's a completely unfair assessment. Nobody ever said that KSG/Harvard guarantees anything. After all, by that same argument, one could say that you shouldn't go to a top MBA program either, because there are some grads from those programs who can't find good jobs. For example, during the dotcom bust, there were a lot of newly minted Stanford MBA's who experienced great difficulty finding work. So does that mean that people would be "fools" to consider Stanford?</p>
<p>Look, there are no guarantees in life. All we can talk about are relative boosts to your success.</p>