<p>We have some pretty polarized viewpoints here, but to be fair:</p>
<p>Alumni:</p>
<p>UVA-- Among those who attended the University can be counted Olympic athletes, U.S. senators, best-selling novelists, business leaders, movie and television producers, and diplomats. Go to the link for the complete, exhaustive list</p>
<p><a href="http://www.virginia.edu/notablealumni/%5B/url%5D">http://www.virginia.edu/notablealumni/</a></p>
<p>W and M-- Notable alums include Thomas Jefferson, John Marshall, James Monroe, John Tyler, Gen. Winfield Scott, and Robert Gates (nominated to replace Rumsfeld as Sec'y of Defense)</p>
<p>Selectivity: (Class of 2010)</p>
<p>UVA-- Admissions rate (these adm. rate is one year old): 39%, Range SAT: 1280-1490</p>
<p>W and M-- Admissions rate (the adm. rate is a year old): 34%, Range SAT: 1280-1430</p>
<p>Financial Aid:</p>
<p>UVA is much better in this category. William and Mary only gives 4 total scholarships (not including the Monroe Scholars, which is not a significant amount of money)- 2 of their Murray Scholarships are reserved for in-state students and 2 for OOS.</p>
<p>By the way, jags, pertaining to your quip about W and M notable grads only being from an era where Harvard and W and M were the only schools available- The first President W and M "put out" was Jefferson (late 1770s), when there were actually 9 notable colleges:</p>
<p>-Harvard College (Harvard University)
-The College of William and Mary
-Collegiate School (Yale University)
-College of New Jersey (Princeton University)
-Academy of Philadelphia (University of Pennsylvania)
-King's College (Columbia University in the City of New York)
-College of Rhode Island (Brown University)
-Queen's College (Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey)
-Dartmouth College</p>
<p>Anyway, the bottom line: Both colleges are rooted in tradition, have great academics, and have produced prominent grads.</p>