<p>Since the LAC schools you've listed are comparable academically, I think one of the most important and often overlooked factors you should consider is the location of the college.
Pomona - I don't know much about this LAC, but I know it's in California. Already you've got a drastically different vibe from the East Coast (at least that's what my roommate from California says. ;) </p>
<p>Wellesley - We're in the suburbs about 45 mins - 1hr away from Boston. Boston is a lovely city. It's got plenty of cafes, small museums, historical spots, and students from tons of campuses. Wellesley’s different. It's very very quiet here. Things close early. Some days (cold days) the most activity I see outdoors is the squirrels running around. We call it “the Wellesley bubble:” it’s really cozy but can feel stultifying at times.
As a student, you can definitely take advantage of events held by other campuses (Harvard, MIT, BU, BC, blahblah) but if you want to focus on your studies or things happening on campus, that's fine too. </p>
<p>Just a warning: the weather can really suck in New England.</p>
<p>Barnard - NYC. I absolutely love NYC, but it can be disorienting at first, to say the least. Of course there are pros and cons to be located right smack dab in the (best) city (in the world), but one con most relevant to me is the fact that it offers so many/too many things in the city. I'm at Wellesley, a quiet campus, and yet I feel like there are so many concerts, culture shows, Jane Austen movie nights, zoomba classes, lectures, etc. that I want to attend! At NYC, I'd be so overwhelmed with choices. Not only do you want to make friends within your campus, you'd want to explore and take advantage of what NYC has to offer - and it has A LOT to offer (internships, museums, concerts, famous premieres, yummy restaurants), which isn't a bad thing. I think, however, that you'll need to be an excellent prioritizer.</p>
<p>Oh another note - Nightlife is kind of lame in Boston compared by NYC. </p>
<p>Hope that helps…</p>