<p>i will provide my own gist and answer AMorrison’s question, i took a 4k class frosh year, and it was fine, but i was prepared for it, i think it depends who you are, and also whether or not you have the prereqs for it, regardless you can do shopping to figure that out. culpa is a life saver i’d say more for upper level classes than lower level because teacher turnover is so much higher for a 1k, 2k class than a 4k class.</p>
<p>Favorite: LitHum 2nd half (6), Art Hum (2), University Writing (4), Intermediate Macro Econ (3), Scientific Revolution (5), Modernism (6), Econ His of LatAm (3), Intro Catalan (4)</p>
<p>Least Favorite: this core class for hispanic studies (1), lat am civ (2), radical traditions with foner (5 - worst lecture course i took, best TA section though), intro stat b (3 - taught by a grad student who had trouble teaching)</p>
<p>Best classes always were with the best professors. Of the ones on my list, ironically enough some of the worst were with well-known professors, some of the best with grad students or young ttrack profs. Some were huge lectures, others small seminars. In general I only had 3 bad experiences at columbia, each is on this above list. The first because of extenuating circumstances, the second because of too high expectations, and the third because of just an unprepared instructor.</p>
<p>But 3 out of 40 aint bad, the rest were rich, fun, and continue to be sources of inspiration in grad work, and gave me a broad understanding of how things work with each other. I am a huge fan of profs at Columbia, I think that they are really talented teachers, and in the end it is why I post so much about it - to really hammer it in that you have dozens of reasons to apply to Columbia, but of the most relevant to it being an educational institution, you really have nothing to sweat, you’ll find far more amazing experiences than ‘eh’ ones. I actually wanted to list off more for favorites, but I thought it might make me seem lame and bookish.</p>